Credit Card Vs Cash: Which to Use and Why [2025]
By Maddy Scheckel I used to be like most Americans who are neck deep in over $5,000 of credit card debt.
I would lay awake at night thinking up new ways to earn extra cash.
Thankfully, I was able to climb out of my hole of debt and have since established disciplined spending habits.
This is why I want to share with you why I’m a fan of both credit cards and cash.
The one that’s best for you will depend on your unique financial situation and needs.
So to make your decision easier, I’ll cover the benefits of using a credit card vs cash. I also go over the best times to use each and why.
Is it Better to Use Credit Card or Cash?
Source: Unsplash
Credit card vs cash. Which should you use to make purchases?
They both offer unique pros and cons.
If you’re a responsible consumer who pays their account balance every month, then credit cards may be the better option.
Credit cards offer features that many debit cards don’t. Some of these features include fraud protection, return protection, and cashback rewards.
Credit cards are also an excellent way to build credit when you use them responsibly.
Consistently paying your credit card bill on time will show lenders that you are accountable for the money you borrow. This helps you qualify for lower interest rates, which is especially useful if you’re planning to finance a large purchase in the future.
However, not everything about credit cards is positive.
Credit cards tend to have high-interest rates, so if you struggle with poor spending habits or you’re already trying to pay off debt, opting for cash would be the safer way to go.
Credit cards can tempt you to spend more than you have.
For instance, if you’re going out with friends and have a few hundred dollars in your pocket, you can only spend that money.
With a credit card, you might have a limit of several thousand dollars, making it easy to overspend.
See how much you could save by learning how to cancel all subscriptions on your debit card or credit card.
When to Use a Credit Card
Source: Unsplash
When do I recommend using a credit card vs cash?
Consider the following situations.
While Traveling
Using a credit card when traveling is a must.
It’s safer because if you lose your card, simply report it and request a new one. With physical cash, there’s not much you can do once it’s lost.
Some credit cards also provide multi-currency options, so it’s easy to manage your funds in different countries. This is handy if you’re traveling to multiple countries within a short timeframe.
Travel tip: Although you’re using your credit card for most of your purchases, it’s still a good idea to carry small amounts of cash. Local vendors might not accept cards, and if your bank locks your card for some reason, cash can act as a safety net.
When Shopping Online
Credit cards also offer fraud protection.
If your credit card details somehow get leaked online and someone maxes out your credit card, you most likely won’t have to pay for these fraudulent purchases.
When to Use Cash
You may want to consider avoiding credit cards and using cash in the following situations.
When Making Small Purchases
Cash is usually a better option for making small purchases, such as a pack of gum or a cup of coffee.
This is because some stores won’t allow you to swipe your card unless your checkout total exceeds a minimum, say $5 or $10.
When Paying Off Debt
Cash is also more suitable if you’re struggling to get rid of debt.
Unlike credit cards, you can only spend the cash you have.
You’ll be getting rid of the temptation to overspend that comes with high credit card limits.
Why Use a Credit Card?
Many credit card vs cash videos online will tell you to avoid credit cards.
Here’s an example:
And while they do have some valid points, there are also several benefits to using a credit card.
1 – Better Fraud And Return Protection
One of the reasons why credit cards are so popular is because of their fraud protection.
Many top credit card companies offer zero fraud liability on purchases you didn’t make.
In other words, if you’re a victim of identity theft and someone runs up your credit balance, you won’t owe a penny.
While debit cards do offer some fraud protection, it usually isn’t as advanced as credit cards.
Credit cards also provide return protection.
Not entirely sure what return protection is?
It works like this: Let’s say you bought something and want to return it, but the store doesn’t accept returns anymore. With return protection, you get an extended return window or, sometimes, can return the product directly to your credit card company for a refund.
2 – It Helps Build Your Credit
Another benefit of credit cards is that they can help you grow your credit.
By making payments on time and not racking up a lot of debt, you may also qualify for lower-interest loans in the future.
Credit card companies aren’t able to track cash transactions. So if you only use cash, they won’t be able to tell if you’re a responsible consumer.
In addition, you’ll need a credit history (and decent score) to apply for things like mortgages or car loans.
3 – Get Rewards And Cashback
Major credit card companies often offer rewards, points, and cashback for shopping with their cards.
You’ll be getting rewarded for purchases you were already going to make!
Some credit cards even offer up to 6% cash back on certain categories.
This can help stretch your monthly budget further.
Why Use Cash?
Source: Unsplash
Buying stuff with cash has benefits too.
1 – To Reduce Debt
One of the biggest reasons consumers prefer cash and debit cards is the lack of high-interest rates.
Credit cards can have interest rates of over 20%!
So, if you’re struggling to pay off your credit card debt, switching to cash or a debit card is a good idea.
This allows you to avoid high-interest debt and any penalties triggered by late payments.
2 – It’s More Versatile
Cash tends to be more versatile than credit cards.
Not all stores accept credit cards, and those who do might require you to spend a minimum amount before you can swipe your card.
With cash, you have more flexibility.
Almost all stores accept cash, and you can use it to pay, regardless of your checkout total.
3 – To Save Money
Research by Shift Credit Card Processing found that when consumers use a credit card, they spend 83% more.
Sticking to only cash or a debit card keeps you from spending more than you have.
Personally, I’d find it easy to overspend on things I don’t need with a high limit credit card. I’d tell myself, “I can pay this off later” instead of only spending within my means.
Commonly Asked Questions About Credit Card Vs Cash
Is It Bad to Use a Credit Card?
Using a credit card isn’t inherently bad, but it depends on how you use it. If you stick to your budget and pay your credit card on time, it can help you build good credit. However, credit cards can get you into debt quickly if you don’t control your spending.
Is It Better to Use Cash or Credit When Traveling?
A credit card is generally a better option when traveling because it’s safer. If you lose your card, all you have to do is report it and get a new one. But, I still recommend carrying some cash in case some stores don’t accept credit cards or to hold you over in between cards.
Why is Paying With a Credit Card Better Than Cash?
Choosing between credit cards vs cash will depend on your financial needs. Some consumers find that credit cards let them spread payments across several months and receive cashback rewards. In contrast, others feel that cash makes sticking to a budget easier and is a foolproof way to stay out of debt.
Do Rich People Use Cash or Credit Cards?
Even though rich people can afford to pay for everything outright, they tend to use both cash and credit cards. Cash allows them to avoid high-interest rates, and credit cards offer cashback rewards, fraud protection, and other perks.
Why Do People Use Cash Instead of Credit?
Many people use cash instead of credit because they find it easier to spend only what they have. For example, if you have $200 in your pocket, you can’t really spend more than that $200. But with high credit card limits, it’s easy to spend money that you don’t have.
Why is Cash Better Than Credit?
People like cash because they don’t want to use credit to make purchases. However, this doesn’t mean cash is better than credit. Each has pros and cons. The one that’s right for you will depend on your financial situation and goals.
Cash Vs Credit Card Similarities?
Cash and credit cards both allow you to spend money. You can buy goods or services in person with either one. They also both enable consumers with the ability to control their finances in a way that aligns with their future goals.
Cash Vs Credit Cards Pros and Cons
Cash lets you stick to a budget easier because you can’t spend money that you don’t have. However, you won’t be able to build a good credit history. On the other hand, credit cards are convenient and offer cashback, but the high-interest rates can quickly get you into more debt.
If you need help fixing your credit, check out our comparison of Credit Saint vs Lexington Law, or see if working with the best tradeline companies could be the right credit repair solution for you.
Meanwhile, learn how to budget for non recurring expenses so you can be prepared for unexpected costs going forward.
If you’re looking for a low-tech, hands-on budgeting method, learn about cash envelope categories. And if you need to boost your savings fast, the 60/30/10 rule budget can help.
Why Debit Cards Are Better Than Cash?
Debit cards are better than physical cash because it’s safer. If you lose your debit card, you can lock it, report it, and request a new one. But if you’re carrying cash and you lose it, it’s unlikely you’ll get it back.
